Average

Benchmark Full Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Benchmark Full Proof
Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

62.5% ABV
$22
Website
Benchmark Full Proof 62.5% ABV Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

What the Distillery Says:

Benchmark Full Proof is a 125-proof Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey produced by Buffalo Trace Distillery as part of the Benchmark premium line extensions. Bottled at the original barrel entry proof, this expression offers an intense, uncut flavor profile while remaining an accessible everyday pour.

The nose opens with rich oak, toasted brown sugar, deep caramel, and robust vanilla. On the palate, it delivers bold notes of dried cherries, baking spice, charred wood, and dark chocolate, leading into a long, warming finish with lingering spice and toasted oak.

What Gary Says

Nose: Salted caramel, vanilla, oak, cast-iron corn bread, baking spices with brown sugar.
Palate: Butterscotch with hot cinnamon candy, oak, vanilla, brown sugar, cloves, cocoa and chili oil.
Finish: Short, drying with cinnamon, pepper spice and bit of leather.
Comments: Appreciate the higher ABV here when compared to Top Shelf, but this might drink even hotter than it is! Good news is that this takes water well, bringing out some fruit notes on the nose, and more of a caramel coffee cake note on the palate. Although even with a bit of water it still drinks hotter to me than it is (out of the bottle, if someone asked me to guess I would think this is approaching hazmat territory). It does well in a cocktail, where I found the Top Shelf is only serviceable.

Rating: Average/Stands Out

Benchmark Full Proof Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Read More »

Benchmark Top Floor Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Benchmark Top Floor
Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

43% ABV
$15
Website
Benchmark Top Floor 43% ABV Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

What the Distillery Says

The top floors of our aging warehouses experience the most extreme temperature fluctuations, pulling the whiskey deeper into the wood of the barrel. Benchmark Top Floor is aged on these upper floors to impart a richer flavor and distinctive character into the whiskey. Bottled at 86 proof, this expression features aromas of honey and baking spices, with a palate of rich vanilla, caramel, and light oak, leading to a smooth, lingering finish.

What Gary Says

Nose: Charred oak, vanilla, corn bread with honey, hint of caramel with baking spices.
Palate: Corn flakes with caramel, toasted oak, vanilla, nutmeg and a hint of citrus zest.
Finish: Short and drying with pepper spice, oak and vanilla.
Comments: Interesting to showcase the impact of aging on the top floor, where extreme temperatures bring the oak and other flavors forward. Based on as corny as this is, it can’t be much over four years old (no age statement and ‘straight bourbon whiskey’ would set that as the floor). Not objectionable, but for an extra $3 or $4 I would spring for Evan Williams Bottled in Bond personally.

Rating: Average

Benchmark Top Floor Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Read More »

Old Fitzgerald 7 Year Bottled-in-Bond

Old Fitzgerald 7 Year Bottled-in-Bond
Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

50% ABV
$60
Website
Old Fitzgerald 7 Year Bottled-in-Bond

What the Distillery Says

Old Fitzgerald Bourbon has a long history of excellence dating back to 1870. Today, Old Fitzgerald 7-Year-Old Bottled-in-Bond is the signature flagship expression from Heaven Hill Distillery, marking 155 years after the trademark honoring John E. Fitzgerald was first introduced.

Produced under the exacting standards of the Bottled-in-Bond Act of 1897, this wheated Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey is distilled from a mashbill of 68% corn, 20% wheat, and 12% malted barley. After aging for seven years in Level 3 charred new American oak barrels, the Bourbon is bottled at exactly 100 proof (50% ABV).

“Seven years proved to be a sweet spot for a Whiskey that already transcends expectations for a wheated Bourbon,” said Master Distiller Conor O’Driscoll. “This refined Bourbon carries the same layered elegance its longer-aged sibling made famous, and the same commitment to excellence found in every bottle from Heaven Hill Distillery.”

TASTING NOTES
Color: Bright copper.
Aroma: Graham crackers and honey. Light citrus and summer fruit notes.
Taste: Rich and viscous. Fresh bread, brown sugar, and baking spices.
Finish: Long-lasting richness, brown sugar sweetness with cinnamon fades to a hint of oak.

What Gary Says

Nose: Vanilla, honey, soft oak, apricot jam with a hint of orange zest
Palate: Thick mouthfeel with honey, vanilla, caramel, graham cracker, apricot, cherry & cinnamon.
Finish: Moderate length with cinnamon, honey & citrus fruit notes.
Comments: As a wheater, it is more gentle than a rye mash bourbon. This is very soft. While 7 years is a respectable age, it just isn’t squarely in my wheelhouse (maybe at a higher ABV). I think back to 15 years ago when could get Old Weller Antique 107 at 7 years old, which was right in my sweet spot (yet Weller Special Reserve at 45%ABV and 7 years was absolutely not). This is better than WSR to my recollection, but at $60 it’d be tough to pick up.

Rating: Average/Stands Out

Old Fitzgerald 7 Year Bottled-in-Bond Read More »

Penelope Architects of Golf Hole 1

Penelope Architects of Golf Hole 1 Aged 6 Years
Straight Bourbon Whiskey Finished with American Oak Staves

47% ABV
$60
Website
Penelope Architects of Golf Hole 1 Bourbon
We would like to thank Luxco and The Brand Guild for sending us samples to review.

What the Blender Says

Penelope began with two friends, 18 holes, and the kind of conversation that turns a dream into something bigger.

Architects of Golf honors that moment – and the game that gave the idea room to grow.

The collection captures that spirit, celebrating the belief that great things often begin in simple moments among friends, brought to life through three new bourbon expressions

“Golf and bourbon are similar in that they both bring people together. Penelope started as an idea on a golf course, so we felt it was only natural to expand our Architect line into this area,” says Michael Paladini, Founder and Vice President of Strategy at Penelope Bourbon. “Architects of Golf is a nod to the subtleties of the game and where some of our best ideas took shape. The introduction of American Oak Staves into our blends reflects how small adjustments can have a big impact on the overall product.”

Reflecting the progression of a round of golf itself, the Architects of Golf collection features three distinct expressions — Hole 1, Hole 2, and Hole 3 — each building on the last through distinct stave finishing techniques implemented at different intensities and over different lengths of time, inviting consumers to slow down, connect, and savor the experience:

Architects of Golf Hole 1 opens with aromas of caramel and butterscotch layered with baking spices and nutmeg. On the palate, dark chocolate, sweet oak, and roasted nuts lead into a finish of lingering sweet oak, vanilla, subtle leather, and spice, delivering a smooth, balanced introduction to the series.

Architects of Golf Hole 2 delivers a more structured profile, opening with aromas of butterscotch, baking spices, and sweet fruit. On the palate, dark chocolate, butterscotch, vanilla, and French toast build layered richness, leading into a finish of lingering sweet oak, vanilla, subtle leather, and spice for a deeper, more robust expression.

Architects of Golf Hole 3 showcases the most robust stave influence of the three, with prominent vanilla layered over rich toast and baking spice. Aromas of caramel and dried red fruit lead into a fuller palate of chocolate mousse, vanilla, and lingering oak, finishing with toasted oak, cherry, and dark chocolate for a layered, concentrated profile.

“Each hole represents a distinct batch.” said Danny Polise, Founder and Master Blender of Penelope Bourbon. “They are designed to explore the nuances of different stave profiles and how they evolve the whiskey. It made developing the collection as fun as playing the game.”

HOLE 1 TASTING NOTES
AROMA: Gentle Vanilla and light toasted oak.
BODY NOTES: Subtle baking spice with balanced warmth.
FINISH: Soft fruit with a smooth, easygoing close.

Straight Bourbon Whiskey Finished in American Oak Staves, Non-Chill Filtered

Mashbill
60% Corn
36% Rye
4% Barley Malt

What Gary Says

Nose: Vanilla, honey, toasted oak with hints of orchard fruit.
Palate: Light caramel toffee, vanilla, soft spice notes of nutmeg & cinnamon with oak and hints of maple.
Finish: Short to medium in length, slightly drying with vanilla & dried fruit.
Comments: I like the concept – evolving hole by hole. I probed for more details (is the difference the number of staves, how long they finish) and was informed it was the timing of the stave finishing – not the number (and the timing was 6-7 weeks). With a little more disclosure about the timing, this would be a fun side-by-side tasting for whiskey geeks like myself. They list this first hole as “an approachable intro,” but for me it’s a little unremarkable. It’s OK, and I prefer it with a few drops of water which brings out a bit of cocoa on the nose, and a bit of a nutty milk chocolate note on the palate.

Rating: Average/Stands Out

Penelope Architects of Golf Hole 1 Read More »

Oaklore Port Cask Finished Four Grain Bourbon Whiskey

Oaklore Story Series: Port Cask Finished Four Grain Bourbon Whiskey

46% ABV
$80
Website
Oaklore Port Cask Finish Four Grain Bourbon Whiskey
We would like to thank Oaklore Distilling Co. for sending us a sample to review.

What the Distillery Says

This unique four-grain bourbon brings together wheat, rye, corn, and barley, all aged to perfection for 6+ years. Then, after aging in a new charred white oak barrel, the whiskey is transferred to a newly dumped port wine barrel, where it continues to age for 12-18 months. It then incorporates the rich depth of port wine that lives long into the finish. Once it reaches its fullness of character, it’s then bottled for your enjoyment.
National shipping available late March 2026.

NOSE: Candy Grape, Dark Fruit
PALATE: Warm, Cherry, Whiskey
FINISH: Sweet Oak, Raspberry Sorbet

What Gary Says

Nose: Dark fruit with plums, cherries, raisins, and vanilla.
Palate: Cherry cordial, honey, bit of caramel and cinnamon.
Finish: Moderate in length, drying with red berries and cinnamon.
Comments: This is the second Oaklore product I’ve tried (the Oloroso Sherry finish was the first last year), and is heavy on the port cask finish. If you REALLY like port this may not be a negative – and while it isn’t off putting – it covers up the base four grain bourbon for me. A couple drops of water opens it up more and brings out the caramel more. I am a fan of port, but with the finishing was a little less so that the bourbon might shine through more.

Rating: Average/Stands Out

Oaklore Port Cask Finished Four Grain Bourbon Whiskey Read More »