El Dorado 12 Year Old Finest Demerara Rum
40% ABV
$35
Website
What the Distillery Says
This rum has been laid down in oak barrels for at least 12 years producing a rich and diverse spirit. Blended to perfection using a combination of the Enmore and Diamond Coffey Stills and the Port Mourant Double Wooden Pot Still.
Tasting Notes
Lush tropical fruit and spice nose with hints of honey and dark sugar. The profile is round, mellow and full bodied with rich flavors of fruits and spice. The finish is delightful, elegant and dry.
NOTE: Back in April 2009, El Dorado 12 Yr was actually our 9th review (ever) on this site. My notes below are new, but including both Richard & Matt’s notes from that review below as well.
What Gary Says
Nose: Crème brûlée that’s extra toasty, floral notes, coconut, tobacco, subtle orange zest with bits of toffee.
Palate: Sweet with a touch of candied orange, vanilla, a hint of cinnamon and a slightly sour oak note.
Finish: Short and drying, with a slightly bitter molasses note.
Comments: I’m not a rum aficionado. Richard had bequeathed a sample set from El Dorado which included the 12 yr, 15 yr, and 21 yr for site review – so I assumed (yeah, I know what it means) that it hadn’t been reviewed. It wasn’t until I was putting together the post that I realized the boys had review this over 10 yrs ago. We all had a bit of a different take on this one, although like them I found the nose to stand out while the palate was highly ordinary (and agree with Richard – I don’t buy to just smell!) I will say this isn’t as syrupy sweet as some other rums, which I appreciate.
Rating: Average
What Matt says:
Nose: It has your typical rum notes (vanilla, caramelized sugar), but there are also some botanicals in there. It is almost like a craft gin married with a somewhat typical rum.
Palate: Vanilla, the sugar moves a little toward burnt from the nicely caramelized nose, there is also an oak component.
Finish: Here the sugar moves all the way to burnt with a long alcoholic burn.
Comments: Rum has never been my favorite alcoholic beverage. In my youth, I had too many encounters with inferior rums like Captain Morgan or Bacardi. I did not really appreciate rum until I spent some time in the Caribbean, where rum is a part of the culture. I discovered that rum can be really good. Indeed, rum is starting to become part of the craft distillation movement. This means that rum will be increasingly drinkable as a stand-alone. This rum lives up to those standards. This means that it holds up to being served neat. However, compared to other craft rums, this lacks a little nuance on the palate. The palate just does not deliver what the nose promised. This makes the rating a little difficult. By the standards of every rum on the market, I would say that it stands out, but compared to craft rums it is only average. In fact, I would recommend Appleton’s, a widely available macro-rum, above this one.
Rating: Average
What Richard says:
Nose: Burnt caramel, vanilla, candied apricots, honey-dipped oranges, a hint of mint, floral notes of lavender and…rose? Very, very sweet. You can almost taste the sugar cane through the nose.
Palate: All sugar and alcohol. As lovely as the nose was, the palate is very two dimensional.
Finish: Heavy on the alcohol. It kind of finishes like a strong cough syrup.
Comments: I am admittedly not the most well versed rum drinker. That said, this stands out against your baseline Bacardi and Captain Morgan. That palate and finish aren’t noteworthy but nose is exceptional. But we buy it to drink it not to smell it.
Rating: Average
