2015

George Dickel Rye

George Dickel Rye Whisky
45% ABV
$25
Website
1122817x
What the Distillery Says:
George Dickel Rye Whisky is the only rye finished in the style that made George famous. We start with the finest rye whisky available, made from 95% rye and 5% malted barley. Then we finish it the Dickel way – chilled, then charcoal mellowed.

Spicy and smoky with an exceptionally smooth finish.

What Gary Says:
Nose: Young rye spice, bit of dill, bright but a bit soft
Palate: Citrus spiciness with a hint of pickle and a mellow sweetness
Finish: Moderate, and it seems to get wetter (which I rarely find in a whiskey – odd in that way, but not off putting)
Comments: Dickel has been very transparent (and we appreciate that!) that this rye is distilled by a partner in Indiana, who also distills rye distillate for many NDPs. On the nose, that relationship is pretty clear if you are familiar with some of the others (Bulleit Rye and James E Pepper Rye are two examples). Dickel employs charcoal mellowing when chill filtering the whiskey (although at the time of bottling rather than before aging – again, something different). This adds to the smoothness, and I suspect makes the finish more unique. I am glad they are bottling this at 45% ABV, a tad higher than their Tennessee whiskies, and a tad below some of the other ryes created from the same distillate. For those reasons, I would consider having a bottle around – in particular if you are a fan of rye.
Rating: Stands Out

What Richard Says:
Nose: That minty rye nose jumps out with a creamy herbal backing. It reminds me a bit of Ricola drops. Even though this is contract produced with some tweaks of Dickel’s own it still shows it’s Indiana heritage.
Palate: Sweet mint, a mild bitterness, a pepper back beat.
Finish: Black pepper and mint essential oils that remind a bit of Italian menthol shaving creams.
Comments: With this rye Dickel isn’t your typical non-distilling producer (NDP). First, they use the same charcoal mellowing technique that they do on their Tennessee whiskeys. Second, according to the folks at Dickel this rye is produced using Dickel’s strain of yeast rather than just buying whatever they are making up in Indiana. Those two things make this a distinct contract distilling relationship rather than what I would call a sourced whiskey relationship. It’s made for them in a specific way rather than being made and then subsequently bought by them. So don’t look at it and think just another MGP rye like so many others. It has it’s own unique qualities and stands out from the crowd.
Rating: Stands Out

George Dickel Rye Read More »

George Dickel No 12

George Dickel No 12. Tennessee Sour Mash Whisky
45% ABV
$20
Website
george_dickel12new750__44457.1407758405.1280.1280
What the Distillery Says:
The only 90-proof Tennessee Whisky. We blend older whiskies to achieve deep, assertive flavors with an incredibly smooth finish. Bold and brazen, this is our Superior No. 12.

Concentrated flavors of rich oak and subtle vanilla lead to a long finish with hints of maple, butter and smoke. A whisky with enormous depth, range and personality – considered by many to be the gold standard of Tennessee Whisky.

What Gary Says:
Nose: Buttered corn (boiled, not grilled), honey, hint of vanilla and a medicinal note (iodine?)
Palate: Cream of corn transitioning into corn bread; soft mouthfeel and very smooth.
Finish: Short to moderate in length, with a bit of oak as the corn sweetness abates.
Comments: This corn whiskey is . . . oh, err – this isn’t a corn whiskey; it just tastes like it to me. If you like corn whiskey, that’s good news – I do enjoy that from time to time. Unfortunately like many folks, the label sets my expectations – and seeing “Tennessee Whisky” had me prepared for something closer to Jack Daniels than Mellow Corn. Honestly – if I would have approached this like a corn whiskey, I would have a higher opinion of it. The corn (which is 84% of the mashbill!) dominates every aspect of this whiskey for me, and leaves me wanting more of something (anything) else.
Rating: Average

What Richard Says:
Nose: Buttermilk cornbread (should there ever be any other kind?) fresh from the oven drizzled with wildflower honey. There is also a corn whiskey note that reminds me of sniffing the fermentation tanks when I was there.
Palate: More developed than the No. 8. It’s creamier with more aggressive black pepper and heat to offset the sweetness of the vanilla cream and caramel candies.
Finish: Dark cocoa powder dusted over wet toothpicks.
Comments: First let me say kudos to Diageo for the artificial cork. Those not familiar with my personal disdain for natural corks should read our site more. Getting back to the whiskey, I like the taste of this one. It’s got enough going on to keep me interested. That said, the nose is much younger than the palate and the finish is blah. Definitely a step in the right direction from No.8. I would pick this over a glass of Jack if I was drinking it straight but it’s underwhelming compared to similarly priced bourbons.
Rating: Average

George Dickel No 12 Read More »

George Dickel No 8

George Dickel No 8. Tennessee Sour Mash Whisky
40% ABV
$17
Website
dickel_0020_no_0020_8_0020_P
What the Distillery Says:
The most famous George Dickel whisky. A signature balance of Tennessee whisky flavors, handcrafted for those who want a classic, smooth-sipping experience.

A bold whisky with aromas of light caramel and wood. A smoky finish with hints of maple and buttered corn

What Gary Says:
Nose: Corn bread w/ a bit off drizzled honey, slight medicinal note (iodine?)
Palate: Sweet corn chowder, very soft and creamy, smooth
Finish: Short and sweet.
Comments: If you’re doing a Dickel tasting, definitely start with this (I did it backwards, trying the No 12 first and then the No 8). Both are quite similar, and this reminds me even more of a corn whiskey than what I’ve come to expect as Tennessee whiskey. Basically a younger, lower proof version of the 12. I can’t even refer to this as a “gateway whiskey” for those looking to move from corn to Tennessee whiskey or bourbon, as it doesn’t move far enough out of the “corn” quadrant to count. While it isn’t in my wheelhouse, those who like corn whiskey and a very smooth, easy to drink pour should at least invest $1 or so in a 50 mL of this and see what you think.
Rating: Average

What Richard Says:
Nose: A little bland and uninspired. More closely resembles corn whiskey or new make than an aged product.
Palate: Creamy and sweet with a hint of Luden’s cough drops. It’s not inspiring but it defines the overused adjective “smooth”. You could drink this all day if it didn’t leave you on the floor.
Finish: I’m left with a short finish that has hints of wood, pine straw and chalk.
Comments: I’m not a huge Dickel fan per se. I respect it as a good alternative to Jack Daniels but beyond that in the greater spectrum of bourbon and American whiskey it is just too smooth and easy drinking. It doesn’t have a lot of stand out flavor and there is nothing that makes me want to come back for me. There is nothing off putting either but it’s just bland. This is kind of a whiskey for those that don’t like whiskey.
Rating: Average

George Dickel No 8 Read More »

Distillery Tour: George Dickel (2014)

IMG_0363
George Dickel…the other Tennessee whiskey. That’s not really their slogan but when I first visited Cascade Hollow over ten years ago it kind of felt like that was their only point. Since then they have expanded their product offerings, expanded their tour, and seem to be heading down the path of coming into their own.

My most recent visit to George Dickel was the early part of last year. It was an exceptionally cold spring day but it was also exceptionally beautiful. Those of you who haven’t ventured into the valleys (or “hollers” as they are called) of the Tennessee and Kentucky mountains are missing some truly beautiful country. To get to the distillery you need to take exit 105 off of US interstate 24 regardless of whether you’re coming from Nashville or Chattanooga. If your GPS or Google Maps sends you a different way ignore it. Trust me I’ve made that mistake before. From exit 105 turn right onto highway 41 South. After about 1.5 miles you turn right onto Blanton Chapel Road. Continue on for about 4 miles until you come to a stop sign where you can turn left onto Lyndell Bell Road. Follow the signs to Normandy Dam (3.5 miles) and take a right onto Frank Hines Road. Pass by the Dam and continue on Frank Hines Road into Normandy. With railroad crossing on your right, go straight onto Cascade Hollow Road and follow the signs for 1.5 miles to the George Dickel Distillery and Visitor’s Center. It’s about an hour from Nashville and an hour and a half from Chattanooga.

Now because you are whiskey people you might also be coming from Jack Daniels which is about 20 minutes away. From there take highway 55 to Tullahoma, TN. Turn left on 41A North. Turn right onto Hunters Lane between the Hampton Inn and Ruby Tuesday Restaurant. Turn left at end onto Normandy Road (Hwy. 269) and go approximately 7 miles to Normandy. At stop sign turn right across railroad tracks. Turn right again on Cascade Hollow Road. Distillery is 1.5 miles. I know you are looking at these directions thinking this is some crazy twisty way back into the middle of nowhere. Well, yes it is. Cascade Hollow is a very quiet place. However, if you think this is a crazy way to go then try one of those other routes the Google tries to send you.
IMG_0361
Once you arrive it’s time to begin the tour. They do tours from 9AM to 4:30PM Monday through Saturday. They start every 30 to 45 minutes or so but to be honest it’s pretty laid back and no one seemed in too much of a hurry. There is a basic tour which is free or an extended tour with tasting at the end for $10. Do the $10 tour. You didn’t drive all this way just zip through an abbreviated tour and not taste their whiskey did you?

When we went there were two very lovely Tennessee ladies accompanying us on the tour. They were gracious and thoroughly knowledgeable about the distillery, its history, and its products. After a brief history overview at the visitors center you set out across Cascade Hollow Road and then a small bridge over the creek on your way to the distillery. As you are crossing the lawn that wonderful smell of a sour mash distillery at works wafts towards you. If you like boiled peanuts you’ll love this.
IMG_0360
When you first enter the distillery you are inundated with a wall of noise. It can be a bit hard to hear the guides when the distillery is running. The first stop is the mash tubs where they go over the mash bill (84% Corn/8% Rye/8% Barley), the four hour mashing process, and show you the pumping of the mash up to the fermenters. On the way up they talk about Dickel’s yeast and the three to four day timing of the fermentation which results in their 6% to 8% ABV distiller’s beer. An interesting fact that we picked up was that their rye, while made on contract by MGP in Indiana, actually uses Dickel’s proprietary yeast instead of one of MGP’s yeast strains.

As you are walking around you immediately see how much more manual the Dickel process is than other large U.S. whiskey producers. There’s not a computer terminal in sight. When they say they do it manually, they mean it. Another note of contention is the contract production that is thought to be done at Dickel. Their people swear they don’t make anything other than Dickel because they don’t have the capacity. After seeing how manual their distilling is I can start to believe that.

Next, off to the stillhouse. Just beneath the still is the barreling area which is kind of neat to watch if you can be there when they are barreling. After looking at the stills we go through their distilling process. Their low wines come off a column still at about 115 proof (57.5% ABV). The high wines come off a pot still at about 130 proof (65% ABV). Off the stills the whiskey is chill filtered before going into their mellowing vats. Their reasoning was that George used to prefer the smoothness he got from winter made whiskey over other seasons. Take that for what you will. The mellowing vats have 13 feet of charcoal and perforated plates covered with wool blankets on either side. For an entire batch of distillate to trickle through takes about 7 to 10 days. From there it goes to the barrels.

After leaving the stillhouse you walk past the silos where spent grains are held prior to local farmers picking it up for livestock feed. From there you go into the warehouse where they store the barrels for private selection. The other 12 standard warehouses are on the hills surrounding the distillery. They hold about 198,000 barrels and are six racks high and 25 to 30 barrels deep in the single story warehouses. That single story design means they don’t rotate barrels. This kind of makes sense with their manual work processes. At this point in the tour the guides go through the barrel wood, the maturation process, angels’ share, etc. The No. 8 sits for five to seven years, the No. 12 is eight to ten years, and the Barrel Select is 12 years.

From the private barrel warehouse we head to the media and marketing room where you can see old and new media, photos, advertisements and memorabilia. After that is the obligatory video that marketing takes pride in. The video shows barreling if you didn’t get to see it as well as bottling and the rest of the production process. Due to bottling line capacity constraints the only things bottled on site are the private selection barrels and the Orphan Barrels for parent Diageo. Everything else is loaded onto unmarked tanker trucks and shipped to Diageo’s bottling facility in Plainville, Illinois.

After the video we head off to the tasting room. There we run through the whole line of their standard products (No. 1, No. 8, No. 12, and Barrel Select). After the tasting it’s back to the visitors center to purchase any bottles or memorabilia that may interest you. One note on the bottle purchases. There is a bottle available of private selection (9 year old when we were there) that was picked by their Master Distiller. The ones in your local liquor store picked by the store owners are around $45. The one at the distillery is about $100. The only discernible difference to me is that you get to sign the barrel that it came from there in the visitors center. I don’t know about you but my signature isn’t worth $55. Buyer beware.

Bottle aside, if you are in the area and are a fan of Dickel this is worth a stop. Cascade Hollow is a beautiful part of the country and Dickel offers a nice contrast to larger operations. So stop in, take a tour, enjoy some whiskey, and avoid that gift shop bottle. 😉

Distillery Tour: George Dickel (2014) Read More »

Whiskey Wedge

From time to time we also get requests to take a look at whiskey related books and products in addition to the actual whiskey. Gary was kind enough to take a stab the The Whiskey Wedge by Corkcile which retails for about $17.95 (and is also available on Amazon). Here are his thoughts…

Writing reviews of whiskey is still new territory, although the format is fairly standard (while there are variations, nearly all of us comment on the nose, taste, and finish). How to write a review of a whiskey tool was a challenge. I started with what questions I would want to answer. My list started with these:

  1. How much would the Whiskey Wedge cool my whiskey?
  2. Would whiskey get around the edges of the cube right away, causing it to break away prematurely and become an “obstacle” to pleasant drinking?
  3. How long would it take before the ice would break away from the glass, and how large would the remaining cube be at that time?
  4. What might surprise me along the way that I hadn’t thought of initially?

With those in mind, I started to play with the Whiskey Wedge. After opening the package, I washed the glass and mold – twice. The mold still had a chemical odor, though as long as it doesn’t impart this on the ice (and my whiskey!), it isn’t a big deal (spoiler: it didn’t). After filling the glass per the instructions, it looked like some water may have worked its way around the mold, although it would be a very small amount. Filling right to the fill line is tricky, since the area you are filling is getting smaller and smaller. Twice I over filled, and had to tip the glass on its side to remove some of the water. I’m not sure if having it a bit above the fill line would do any harm, but wanted to follow their instructions as best I could.

Despite this effort, the ice barely came out of the top.
WW1
This made removing the mold a bit of a struggle, but not too bad. I realized that I didn’t know how much the glass would hold – so I started with 2 oz of Stagg Jr. bourbon (134.4 proof, 67-68 degrees F). This left a fair amount of room in the glass, so I added another 2 oz which still left about a ½ inch of room from the lip of the glass.
WW2
For me, 4 oz is a major pour, and likely my only one of the night. After just under 2 minutes, I tested the temperature of the whiskey, and it had already dropped to 48 degrees. While it had cooled quickly, my first couple of sips stilled seemed quite stiff. I noticed that as the ice was melting, the water seemed to be settling at the bottom of the glass, to where the “point” was perfectly clear. I wanted to mix it up a bit, but simply giving the glass a casual turn was not effective. I used my thermometer as a stirrer, which mixed the water and whiskey nicely.
WW3
After 15 minutes, the whiskey was a cool 34 degrees – much colder than other tools I had used (although to be fair, I hadn’t employed a frozen glass with those!). After stirring, the dilution you expect from some ice was working much better – so I definitely recommend employing a stir stick. I sipped the drink for an hour, not coming close to finishing it. At that point, the whiskey had only warmed to 38 degrees – still plenty cold, and syrupy sweet.

Feeling satisfied, I revisited my initial questions.

  1. How much would the Whiskey Wedge cool my whiskey?
    • Quite a bit! From 68 degrees to 34 degrees in 15 minutes, and held it below 40 degrees even an hour later. I was very pleased on this front!
  2. Would whiskey get around the edges of the cube right away, causing it to break away prematurely and become an “obstacle” to pleasant drinking?
    • Another score. I approached this with healthy skeptisicism, and while I certainly wasn’t rooting for failure, I kinda thought it would break off the bottom sooner than I wanted it to. Hell, I even set the glass on the table with some force after 45 minutes, and it never budged. In fact, after one hour, I dumped the remaining whiskey in another glass, and held the Whiskey Wedge upside down over my sink . . . and the cube still stuck like glue to the glass. Again – flying colors in my book.WW4
  3. How long would it take before the ice would break away from the glass, and how large would the remaining cube be at that time?
    • If it would have happened, it would have been more than an hour later – and the cube at one hour was a pretty manageable size (I’d say it was between ¼ and 1/3 the size of the original cube).
  4. What might surprise me along the way that I hadn’t thought of initially?
    • The bit about needing a stirrer is something I hadn’t anticipated. I’m used to just holding the top of my glass and rotating it a bit to mix things up, but that wasn’t very effective given that the cube is stationary.

All in all, if you are looking to chill your whiskey without diluting it too quickly (but still diluting it over time), I have no reservations recommending the Whiskey Wedge (although I would also recommend having a stirrer on hand).

Thanks to Kim Miller at Corkcicle for providing the sample!

– Gary

Whiskey Wedge Read More »