Must Try

Old Forester 1924 10 Year Old

/ / Bourbon, Review / ,

Old Forester 1924 10 Year Old
Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky

50% ABV
$115
Website
Old Forester 1924 10 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whisky

What the Distillery Says

The Whiskey Row Series’ 1924 10 – Year – Old is a limited annual release celebrating another milestone in Old Forester’s storied history.

During Prohibition, more than 200 distilleries were forced to close. Old Forester, however, continued operations because the federal government issued us one of six medicinal licenses, P-3. In 1924, Old Forester acquired barrels from closed distillers, with different mash bills, and bottled that liquid as Old Forester. This release commemorates that moment in time.

Aroma: Soft notes of fudge, cocoa, marzipan, and cured tobacco layered over hints of rich oak and warm cinnamon.
Taste: Chocolate covered graham cracker dusted with cinnamon.
Finish: Hints of spice and graham cracker crumbles.

What Gary Says

Nose: Caramel, fudge, vanilla, walnuts, pipe tobacco, charred oak and a hint of leather.
Palate: Chocolate, vanilla, caramel, walnuts, cinnamon with a hint of cherries and oak.
Finish: Moderately long, drying with toffee and oak spices.
Comments: This drinks well neat but try a couple of drops of water – brings out a bit of citrus on the nose and palate, and also thickens the mouthfeel nicely (borderline creamy). 10 years is a solid age for bourbon in my humble opinion – definitely getting some oak notes but not approaching too much. My only objection on this one is the price. It isn’t insane by today’s standards, but at almost twice the price of Old Forester 1920 – definitely didn’t love it that much.

Rating: Stands Out/Must Try

Old Forester 1924 10 Year Old Read More »

Joseph Magnus Cigar Blend Bourbon Batch 444

/ / Bourbon, Review /

Joseph Magnus Cigar Blend Bourbon
Batch 444

56.63% ABV
$150-300
Website
Joseph Magnus Cigar Blend Bourbon

What the Producer Says

Cigar Blend Bourbon
Bold, rich aromas of tobacco, spice, vanilla, fig, prunes, and dried fruit

Artfully blended to enjoy with a fine cigar. A combination of award-winning Joseph Magnus Bourbon and 11 and 18-year-old whiskeys to assume bold, rich aromas of tobacco, spice, leather, vanilla, blanched almonds, and toffee. The Armagnac cask finish lends fruity notes of fig, prune, and dried apricot.

TASTING NOTES:
Aurora Borealis Batches #437-446
The set of batches that hail from this particular coupe mere are inspired by a host of Scandinavian and other desserts hailing from Northern countries where the Aurora Borealis can be spotted. Dark red berry fruit notes of Hindbæsnitter (Danish raspberry squares), lingonberry jam over dark rye bread, and Våfflor (Swedish waffles) topped with fresh strawberries and whipped cream prevail on the nose, while Cranashan, a famous Scottish dessert of toasted oatmeal, raspberries, toasted oats, cream, and heather blossom honey fills the palate. These berry-filled batches are sure to put stars in your eyes.

What Gary Says

Nose: Dark fruit, tobacco, oak, caramel, cherries, apples, fudge, mineral notes with a hint of cardamon and pipe smoke.
Palate: Creamy mouthfeel with caramel, fruitcake, cinnamon, toffee, blood orange, nutmeg and pepper.
Finish: Moderately long, drying with oak, mint, tobacco and honey.
Comments: This is a lovely dram, and quite fitting for a ‘cigar blend’. I love the tobacco and oak notes which definitely bring me to sitting with a pipe while sipping a fine bourbon. A bit of water brought notes of cheese danish on the nose, and tamped down the pepper on the palate, bringing out honey and peaches. Joseph Magnus batches can vary, and this one in particular has tasting notes shared in batch ranges. They’re not exactly easy to locate (had to thumb through prior months until finding the right range) but they do a great job of calling out the differences.

Rating: Must Try

Joseph Magnus Cigar Blend Bourbon Batch 444 Read More »

Barrell Bourbon Cigar Blend

/ / Bourbon, Review / ,

Barrell Bourbon Cigar Blend
Bourbon Whiskey Finished in Madeira, Armagnac, Rum and Hungarian Oak Casks

55.6% ABV
$85
Website
Barrell Bourbon Cigar Blend
We would like to thank Barrell Craft Spirits and Ro-Bro Marketing & PR for sending us a sample to review.

What the Producer Says

Barrell Cigar Blend Bourbon is a blend of whiskeys aged 7.5 to 18 years finished in Madeira, Armagnac, rum, and Hungarian oak casks, delivering layered notes of dark fruit, molasses, and warm spice. Refined yet expressive, it’s equally compelling with or without a cigar—crafted for slow sipping, long conversations, and a finish designed to linger.

Boston cream pie and grape soda announce that you’re in for a dark, sweet, brandy-inflected bourbon. The barrels have imparted everything from cedar chest to pipe tobacco and pu’er tea. Hungarian oak’s gentle cola spices pervade every part of the drinking experience while the Madeira adds pecan pie to the palate and sweet vermouth to the finish.

APPEARANCE: Maple syrup.
NOSE: The heady, piquant scent of crusty sourdough bread strikes first. A distinctly fruity note plays second fiddle to the toffee, pipe tobacco and dusty cedar chest of the cask’s themselves. The oxidized wine imparts walnuts, dry autumn leaves, and leather of rancid, going as far as miso in the savory direction. As the whiskey breathes, pastries emerge ranging from sticky buns and eclairs to sweet potato pie. Fruits resolve into pear, persimmon, and a splash of grape soda.
PALATE: Warm cola with the cinnamon dialed up. Slightly burnt cornbread, pistachio ice cream, and a vanilla so pungent it’s perfume-like. The texture is big, rich and chewy, full of oils, sugars and tannins. The Armagnac makes its presence felt with dried cherries and dates while the oak brings notes of pu’er tea, and fernet. Underneath that earthiness one finds a bit of dried mushroom and soy sauce.
FINISH: The combination of oak, spice and fortified wine reads as sweet vermouth, as if you’re swallowing a sip of Manhattan. Clove is particularly potent, as is juniper berry and cocoa powder. There’s a rich mineral vein running through it containing slate and salt. As it lingers there’s ample opportunity to focus on facets of rosehips, cinchona bark, black truffle and incense.

WITH A SPLASH OF SPRING WATER: The nose is awash with butterscotch hard candy. Beneath it, it’s mostly the fruits which have been shuffled about, now reading as Mirabelle plum, honeydew melon, and hint of sun-dried tomato. On the palate the rum emerges showing a very clear molasses note backed up by café au lait and cinchona bark.

  • A blend of straight bourbon whiskeys aged 7.5 to 18 years
  • Distilled in Kentucky, Tennessee, and Indiana
  • Finished in Madeira, Armagnac, rum, and Hungarian oak casks
  • Bottled at 111.2 proof
  • Crafted and bottled in Kentucky

What Gary Says

Nose: Musty cigar paper, toffee, dark fruit notes give way to baked pears, light roasted coffee, cedar, oak, worn leather and vanilla.
Palate: Thick mouthfeel with vanilla, black cherry, caramel, brown sugar, honey, oak, cinnamon, pepper spice and a bit of cloves.
Finish: Moderate in length with caramel, rouge vermouth, cocoa and oak.
Comments: When I think of ‘cigar blend’ whiskies, I imagine a whiskey that reminds me a bit of a cigar as well as one I might enjoy simultaneously with a cigar (although this latter is a bit of a stretch for me, as despite several attempts I don’t happen to enjoy cigars – so I’m guessing a bit on this front). The nose on this definitely brings images of a cigar that hasn’t yet been lit (or ‘spiced up’ Arnold Schwarzenegger style; thanks to Big Rich for sharing that video!) But it isn’t one dimensional, and the bourbon shines through along with the wine cask influence, and some hallmarks of well aged whiskey (note not ALL age on whiskey is “well aged”) like worn leather. This is an absolute gem – sips brilliantly neat but also opens up really nicely with a few drops of water (bringing notes of figs and butterscotch).  The folks at Barrell Craft Spirits have a long track record of blending and finishing some amazing whiskies, and this is another great example!

Rating: Must Try/Must Buy

Barrell Bourbon Cigar Blend Read More »

High West Bourye 2026

/ / Other Whisk(e)ys, Review /

High West Bourye 2026
Blend of Straight Whiskeys

50.5% ABV
$125
Website
High West Bourye
We would like to thank High West Whiskey and lippe taylor for sending us a sample to review.

What the Producer Says

Bourye invites you in with a bright, inviting nose of candied lemon, apricot jam on buttery shortbread, wrapped in caramel macaron sweetness, spiced cookies, a hint of toasted cinnamon, drifting through an Alpine breeze.

On the palate, grilled peaches and orange blossoms unfold into rich layers of chocolate‑covered haystack, molasses cookies, brown sugar bacon, sarsaparilla, lavender, and warm leather, like stepping into Grandma’s cabin tucked among old-growth oaks.

A luxurious finish of sticky toffee pudding and warm ginger tea leaves a final, irresistible impression.

The 2026 Bourye release features an elevated ABV, which highlights the elegance and complexity of its 10+ year‑old whiskeys while preserving the decadent flavor developed through extended aging.

Mash Bill Details
Straight Bourbon Whiskey: 75% corn, 21% rye, 4% barley malt from MGP; 60% corn, 36% rye, 4% malted barley from MGP
Straight Rye Whiskey: 95% rye, 5% barley malt from MGP; 80% rye, 20% malted rye from HWD

Aging: A blend of straight Bourbon and Rye (BOU + RYE) whiskeys aged a minimum of 10 years (10-19yo)
Availability: National Limited Release
Filtration: No Chill Filtration, No Flavor Added

Nose: Candied lemon, apricot jam on shortbread, caramel macaron, pfeffernüsse spice cookies, toasted cinnamon stick, dried ginger, springtime meadow in the Alps
Palate: Grilled peaches, orange blossom, chocolate-covered haystack, soft molasses biscuit, brown sugar bacon, black licorice, sarsaparilla, lavender, warm brown leather, rustic log cabin
Finish: Sticky toffee pudding with ginger tea
Blend: A unique and premium blend of rich straight bourbon and rye whiskeys, making for a premier sipping whiskey and one of High West®’s all-time favorites.
How to Enjoy: Bourye® is best enjoyed around a campfire while looking at the Milky Way. Sip straight or with a little water. Not recommended with ice.

What Gary Says

Nose: Thick with caramel, toffee, shortbread cookies, graham cracker, slightly burnt brownie, cinnamon, oak, orange zest, hint of maple syrup and leather.
Palate: Creamy mouthfeel with caramel, grilled peaches, brown sugar, cinnamon, anise, cocoa, orange zest, hint of mint with nutmeg.
Finish: Long with honey, cinnamon, a bit of ginger and pepper spice.
Comments: This is NOT your regular, annual release of Bourye folks. I had the pleasure of sitting down with a side-by-side-by-side comparison of batches from 2024, 2025 and this years – and it was not even close. The additional age in this year’s release, plus the higher ABV really put this above the rest – and the rest are pretty damned good! The 2024 and 2025 were fairly similar, but by comparison this had more fruit notes, and more of those candy-bar qualities that I’m a fan of. In short, this is a delicious pour, and agree with the recommendation of sipping neat.

Rating: Must Try

High West Bourye 2026 Read More »

Redbreast 1989 30 Year Old Port Finish

/ / Irish Whiskey, Review /

Redbreast 1989 30 Year Old Port Finish
Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey
The Whisky Exchange Exclusive

57.2% ABV
$900 – $1,800 (initially sold for £675 in 2020)
Website
Redbreast 1989 30 Year Old Port Finish TWE Exclusive Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey 57.2%

What the Retailer Says

A limited-edition 1989 Redbreast single pot still Irish whiskey, bottled exclusively for The Whisky Exchange. Initially matured in ex-bourbon barrels, it was re-casked in 1995 into a Port cask from the Douro Valley in Portugal. Rich aromas of dried mango, plums, dark berries, oak, vanilla and coffee fill the nose, complemented by notes of cinnamon, exotic fruits, dark berries, vanilla and toasted oak.
Cask #: 38635
Number of Bottles: 444

Tasting Notes From The Producer
Nose: Rich medley of fruits, from sweet mango to fleshy ripe plums to dark berry fruits. The oak adds notes of toasted wood with touches of vanilla, brown sugar and roasted coffee beans along with a mild touch of leather. Pot still spices continue to build and evolve overtime adding further depth and complexity.
Palate: Initial notes of cinnamon spice and soft wood tannins along with exotic fruits and dark berries. Rich mouth-coating texture with sweet notes of vanilla and treacle toffee layered over a toasted oak foundation.
Finish: Lingering with the ripe fruits and pot still spices having the final word.

Tasting Notes From Billy Abbott, The Whisky Exchange
Nose: All of the fruit, from the fresh to the exotic, dried, and imaginary. Gummi bears, apples, pears, mango, pineapple, sultanas, raisins: if you can think of it, it’s probably here. Along with the fruit is aromatic old oak, many times polished, brown sugar and gentle spice.
Palate: Rich and rounded on the tongue, with toffee and caramel leading to the intense fruit of the nose. The tropical notes sit up front, with rich and sweet raisins, glacé cherries and plums sitting behind. Aniseed and cinnamon spice bring up the rear, with a touch of menthol freshness.
Finish: Brown sugar and cinnamon dusted pastry cases, filled with fruit. Gentle aniseed spiciness lingers.
Comment: One of the fruitiest whiskies I’ve ever tried, mixing classic, old-Irish tropical- and orchard-fruit notes with rich, dark dried fruit. It’s complex, layered and both rewards and deserves long consideration.

What Gary Says

Nose: Robust dark fruits, plums, poached pears, mango, berry compote, toasted oak and leather.
Palate: Thick and syrupy with dark fruits leaning towards tropical with coconut and mango, dark chocolate toffee, cinnamon, nutmeg, cherries and honey.
Finish: Long and slightly drying with fading fruit and spice notes.
Comments: This is an absolute gem. Probably 4 of my top 5 ever tastes of Irish whisky have been exclusive offerings by The Whisky Exchange (so thanks to them, but also my good fortune to have friends who gift me samples of these fine bottles!) This is intense, and amazing neat – although if you add a few drops of water it brings the fruit more into that tropical lane. Just delightful!

Rating: Must Try

Redbreast 1989 30 Year Old Port Finish Read More »