Rye Whiskey

Sagamore Spirit Barrel Select Rye Whiskey

/ / Review, Rye Whiskey /

Sagamore Spirit Barrel Select Rye Whiskey
Total Wine Selection

52.5% ABV
$65-80
Website
Sagamore Spirit Barrel Select Rye Whiskey

What the Producer Says

Barrel Select Rye Whiskey
The Sagamore Spirit Barrel Select program is a unique Maryland-style blend of 7-year-old straight rye whiskies. Each barrel of high-rye is expertly blended with a low-rye mash bill by our distilling team. No two expressions taste the same, and you are guaranteed to enjoy a one-of-a-kind product. The Sagamore Spirit Barrel Select program showcases the uniqueness of our distillers’ favorite barrels in each bottle.

Tasting Notes
Palate: Classic tasting notes include hints of caramel and vanilla with cinnamon and clove.
Age: 7 Years

What Gary Says

Nose:  Rye spice with fennel, dill, tarragon, mint, toasted oak, bright citrus with notes of lemon and lime.
Palate:  Creamy mouthfeel, vanilla then sharpens to grapefruit, lemon, a bit of orange, toffee, cinnamon and honey.
Finish:  Moderately long with grapefruit, cinnamon and vanilla.
Comments:  Just delightful! Honestly I am normally not a fan of grapefruit notes in my whiskey, but this has a lot going on beyond that. From what I see the price points on these vary quite a bit, with some folks snagging for $65 but $80 seems to be the SRP.

Rating: Must Try

Sagamore Spirit Barrel Select Rye Whiskey Read More »

High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram Act 13 (2025)

/ / Review, Rye Whiskey /

High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram
Blend of Straight Rye Whiskeys Finished in Port Barrels
Act 13 (2025 release)

49.3% ABV
$150
Website
High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram Act 13
We would like to thank High West Whiskey and lippe taylor for sending us a sample to review.

What the Producer Says

Dram is our beloved flagship whiskey, “Rendezvous” (a blend of straight rye whiskeys ranging in 4 to 10 years of age), finished in Ruby and Tawny Port barrels.

Nose: Crushed blackberries, mandarin zest, almond shortbread, fig jam, dulce de membrillo, allspice, old vine zinfandel, plum syrup spilled on a mahogany table
Palate: Marionberry preserves, chocolate-dipped cherries, marble rye bread, mochaccino, cinnamon bark, oolong tea, winter pine, smoldering Havana cigar
Finish: Velvety and spiced–chai cold foam, clove-studded orange flesh, soft ginger chew

How to drink: We recommend that you enjoy this special spirit neat, due to its many layers of complexity, next to a warm fire as the snow piles up on the window sill.

What Gary Says

Nose:  Dark fruit, plums, blackberries, figs, heavy port, allspice and orange zest.
Palate: Blood orange, plum, cinnamon, bitter chocolate, nutmeg, cloves and sour oak.
Finish: Moderate in length, drying with citrus spice and cloves fading.
Comments:  I reviewed this back in September of 2020, and while I had two samples from different batches (Act 4 and Act 7), they were so similar I decided not to distinguish.  I no longer have anything left from those samples (or samples of other acts I’ve received), so I can’t provide a true ‘side-by-side’ comparison; but either my tastes have changed (entirely possible) or the whiskey has (also entirely possible).  This was one of my favorites from High West when it was first released – “Christmas in a Bottle” is who I would describe it. This year’s release seems to be more heavy handed on the Port finish, losing some of the spice notes from the rye.  I don’t know if the type of port casks have changed, or the duration of finishing – but while this was good it wasn’t as squarely in my wheelhouse as previous releases.  Coupled with the price increasing makes this a bit disappointing.  I certainly hope that this is just an off year (or an off batch).

Rating: Stands Out

High West A Midwinter Night’s Dram Act 13 (2025) Read More »

West Overton Keystone Rye

/ / Review, Rye Whiskey /

West Overton Keystone Rye
Special Collaboration with Stoll & Wolfe Distillery

54% ABV
$75 (375 ml)
Website
West Overton Keystone Rye
We would like to thank Stoll & Wolfe Distillery and The Whiskey Bard for sending us a sample to review.

What the Producer Says

Age: 3 Years
Mash Bill: A blend of 95% Stoll & Wolfe (60% Rye, 30% Corn, 10% Malt) and 5% WO Monongahela Rye (80% Rye, 20% Malt)
Cask Types: 53 gallon barrel 2 yr air dried staves for the S&W (American oak); WO is American oak
Things to Note: Historic collaboration with West Overton (Distillery of Abraham Overholt)

Tasting Notes
Nose: Aromas of citrus oil, dried mint, and stone fruit rise from the glass, layered with toasted oak and a hint of cherry.
Palate: The palate opens with bold rye spice—black pepper, clove, and ginger—balanced by the depth and natural sweetness of the Rosen rye. Notes of fig, dark honey, and rye bread develop into warm oak and leather.
Mouthfeel: The mouthfeel is full and slightly chewy, with a firm structure that carries through to the finish.
Finish: Lingering notes of cinnamon, cocoa, and dry oak round it out with warmth and complexity.

What Gary Says

Nose: Strong rye spice notes with mint, time, oak funk and cedar.
Palate: Thick mouthfeel with caramel, honey, cloves, cinnamon, mint and orange bitters.
Finish: Long, slightly drying with rye spice notes trailing.
Comments: Apologies in advance for this note which many of you may not be able to relate to very well (just not sure how else to describe it), but this reminds me of ‘dusty rye; – like how rye tasted before rye started making a comeback a dozen or more years ago. It leaves me super curious about how the Stoll & Wolfe Pennsylvania Straight Rye Whiskey tastes at this ABV (as that’s 95% of the blend) versus what the West Overton Monongahela rye. This drinks like a more mature whiskey than 3 years old. It is a tad sharp, but I don’t mind that in a rye whiskey (in fact expect a certain amount of that). Just a delicious, spicy spirit perfect for a crisp fall day! This is a limited release, on sale only at the distillery – so if you’re in the area get it while you can!

Rating: Must Try

West Overton Keystone Rye Read More »

Stoll & Wolfe Pennsylvania Straight Rye Whiskey

/ / Review, Rye Whiskey / ,

Stoll & Wolfe Pennsylvania Straight Rye Whiskey

45% ABV
$48
Website
Stoll & Wolfe Pennsylvania Straight Rye Whiskey
We would like to thank Stoll & Wolfe Distillery and The Whiskey Bard for sending us a sample to review.

What the Distillery Says

Stoll & Wolfe have moved to the forefront of a crowded whiskey landscape by using recipes and methods passed down by Legendary Pennsylvania Master Distiller Dick Stoll. The distillery has been a vital part of reviving whiskey making in small-town Pennsylvania. The collection of Stoll & Wolfe spirits embodies the style and 250-year history of distilling in Lancaster County.

Both the Pennsylvania Straight Rye Whiskey, distilled by Dick Stoll, and the Blend of American Straight Whiskeys, with casks selected and blended by Dick Stoll, have been heavily awarded. Both spirits received scores from the Ultimate Spirits Challenge indicating whiskies that are both highly recommended and excellent in quality. These two flagship bottles were each awarded a Silver Medal at the 2019 San Francisco World Spirits Competition – in the Rye Whiskey and American Whiskey categories respectively. Among the awards, both spirits finished as Chairman’s Trophy finalists in their categories with a Top 3 Finish. Stoll & Wolfe has continued to build upon the legacy of Dick Stoll and the early success of these spirits by expanding to a number of whiskey variations and other distilled offerings. Stoll & Wolfe offerings are available in both the tasting room for purchase and pickup or online for shipping nationwide. View our online shop to try one of Pennsylvania’s most authentic whiskies.

Age: 3 Years
Mash Bill: 60% Rye, 30% Corn, 10% Malt
Cask Types: Zak Cooperage 2 Year air dried staves American oak
Things to Note: Non-Chill Filtered, Sweet Mash Kline Farm Grain

Tasting Notes
Nose: Bright and grain-forward with aromas of rye spice, lemon peel, dried mint, and toasted oak. Subtle notes of cinnamon and orchard fruit peek through with time in the glass.
Palate: Focused and expressive. Classic Pennsylvania rye character comes through with black pepper, clove, and dry herbal notes, rounded out by hints of honey, toasted grain, and dried fruit.
Mouthfeel: Firm and structured with a dry edge and chewy grain texture that lingers.
Finish: Long and spice-driven with lingering notes of cracked pepper, oak, and dutch cocoa.

What Gary Says

Nose: Bright rye spice – mint, thyme, dill with some lemon zest and oak.
Palate: Thick mouthfeel with honey, vanilla, cloves, tangerines, mint and pepper.
Finish: Moderately long with pepper spice followed by cloves and oak.
Comments: Rye whiskey is the only category of whiskey that I find enjoyable at under 4 years old (and not ALL rye whiskey fits that description). For a three year old rye, this punches well above it’s weight! The non-chill filtering really shines through, and the spices in this dram – I would have guessed it was more like an 80% rye (although it doesn’t have that crisp edge that a higher rye would have). This is just delightful! I would love to try this with a few more years of maturity, and a higher ABV (maybe a limited edition in the future, maybe straight, 5 year old cask strength? A guy can dream, right?)

Rating: Stands Out/Must Try

Stoll & Wolfe Pennsylvania Straight Rye Whiskey Read More »

Blue Note Honey Rye Cask 2025 Release

/ / Review, Rye Whiskey / ,

Blue Note Honey Rye Cask 2025 Release
Straight Rye Whiskey Finished in Honey Barrels

58.245% ABV
$65
Website
Blue Note Honey Rye Cask 2025
We would like to thank B.R. Distilling Co and Ro-Bro Marketing & PR for sending us a sample to review.

What the Producer Says

Blue Note Honey Rye Cask begins its journey by embracing the art of fusion. American oak barrels used for finishing are repurposed to produce a delicious, locally sourced, barrel-aged honey. We then return the bourbon to these honey-infused casks for another round of aging to create a distinct and harmonious profile. Blue Note’s bold and spicy notes blended with nuanced flavors of wildflower honey guarantee that with each sip, you’ll enjoy an intricate balance strength and sweetness.

Honey Rye Cask Tasting Notes
Nose: Very Light Apricot, Vanilla, All Spice, and Oak
Taste: Caramel, Hints of Apricot, Oak, Floral Finish, All Spice
Finish: Soft and Balanced, Light texture with lingering hints of Wildflower and Honey

Blue Note Honey Rye Whiskey is now available for purchase online at BlueNoteBourbon.com and in select U.S. markets. Approximately 13,000 bottles are available for the suggested retail price of $64.99.

Blue Note’s whiskey portfolio is distilled in partnership with Lofted Spirits (parent company of Green River Distilling Company) and then aged just north of downtown Memphis where the Mississippi and Wolf Rivers collide. The long summers filled with infamous Memphis heat and cooler evenings forces the whiskey deep into the oak, creating an unmistakably rich flavor that’s bold yet smooth.

Technical Details
AGED: A minimum of three years
PRODUCT TYPE: Straight Rye Whiskey
MASH BILL: 95% Rye and 5% Malted Barley
PROOF & FILTRATION: 116.49 Proof, Unfiltered
Crafted in Memphis, TN

What Gary Says

Nose: Honey, caramel, mint, oak, vanilla wafers and brown sugar.
Palate: Creamy mouthfeel with honey, cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg, chocolate, apricots, apple and a bit of mint.
Finish: Moderate in length with honey, spices and a touch of oak.
Comments: Similar to the Blue Note Honey Bourbon Cask, honey is prominent here. While I enjoyed that quite a bit, I like this even better as the spiciness of the rye gives this more balance. I’ve also always found that at three years old, rye can be ready and enjoyable where bourbon needs just a bit longer. This is a really nice pour, and this replaces the Blue Note Honey Bourbon Cask as my favorite selection from Blue Note! My one critique would be the price, but as a limited edition offering that’s less of an issue.

Rating: Stands Out/Must Try

Blue Note Honey Rye Cask 2025 Release Read More »