January 2026

E&J VS Brandy

E&J VS Brandy

40% ABV
$14
Website
E&J VS Brandy

What the Distillery Says

E&J VS entered the scene in 1975 and has been an OG fan-favorite ever since. Sip it straight-up, or mix it up as a cocktail.

Tasting Notes
Barrel-aged for a minimum of two years
Hints of apple, toasted oak, and vanilla
Crisp and light-bodied

What Gary Says

Nose: Bright, crisp, subtle floral, perfume with grapes.
Palate: Round mouthfeel, light, grapes, bit of baking spices with vanilla and a hint of pears.
Finish: Short to moderate in length, slightly drying with caramel and fading spices.
Comments: Compared to E&J XO Brandy, this is brighter but thinner. Shows that the XO age absolutely makes a difference. For only a dollar or two more, I’d definitely go for the XO and skip this one all together. Don’t get me wrong – this wasn’t bad or anything like that, but just pales in comparison for my money.

Rating: Average

E&J VS Brandy Read More »

Foursquare Master Series Edition No. 1 Rum

Foursquare Master Series Edition No. 1 Rum
Single Blended Rum

62% ABV
$150-$400 (auction only)
Website
Foursquare Master Series Edition No. 1

What the Bottle Says

Foursquare Rum Distillery
Master Series Edition No 1
Single Blended Rum | Fine Barbados Rum
Private Cask Selection | Concierge Total Wine
Aged 12 Years, MMXX Release
Maturation: Ex-Bourbon & Ex-Sherry
62% Alc./Vol.
Distilled, matured and bottled at Foursquare Rum Distillery, Barbados

What Gary Says

Nose:  Banana, charred oak, coconut, tobacco, vanilla and tahini.
Palate:  Thick mouthfeel with dark chocolate, chili oil, caramelized banana, tobacco, vanilla, cinnamon and citrus zest.
Finish:  Long, warm, syrupy, spicy with chocolate, honey and banana.
Comments:  Absolutely not a rum expert, or even afficionado (but am blessed to have friends who gift me samples of lovely things like this, so want to share my thoughts for any who might give a damn). This is a really nice rum! A tad hot on the nose, but intense flavor. A bit of water doesn’t hurt it, and brings out more coconut on the nose while tamping the heat on the palate and bringing some caramel to the party (and while it’s hard to imagine, made the mouthfeel even thicker than it already was). Not sure what this sold for initially, but have seen auction prices ranging from just over $150 (not including shipping/hammer fees) to closer to $400.

Rating: Stands Out/Must Try

Foursquare Master Series Edition No. 1 Rum Read More »

Appleton Estate 12‑Year‑Old Rare Casks Jamaican Rum

Appleton Estate 12‑Year‑Old Rare Casks Jamaican Rum

43% ABV
$43
Website
Appleton Estate 12‑Year‑Old Rare Casks Jamaican Rum

What the Producer Says

The proof that craftsmanship and talent need another ingredient to achieve excellence: Joy

12 Year Old Rare Casks is a true expression of Master Blender Joy Spence’s passion. A blend of rare hand-selected pot and column still rums crafted with limestone-filtered water, all aged for a minimum of 12 years in the tropical climate of Jamaica.

Color: Deep bronze with a honey gold ring of age and mahogany reflections.
Aroma: Toasted oak, dried fruit, and hazelnut, followed by notes of dark cocoa, molasses, orange peel, vanilla, and hints of coffee.
Finish: Long, bittersweet, and luscious.

What Gary Says

Nose:  Banana nut bread with tropical fruit notes of coconut, mango, vanilla, oak and a hint of maple.
Palate:  Sweet caramel, vanilla, milk chocolate, unsweetened coconut, bit of maple, candied grapefruit and subtle spice notes.
Finish:  Short to moderate in length, with cotton candy, caramel and pepper spice.
Comments:  Continuing with another rum, this one is quite different from the Foursquare offering. On the palate, this reminds me a bit of a bourbon. Enjoyed the tropical fruit notes, and very easy to drink.

Rating: Stands Out

Appleton Estate 12‑Year‑Old Rare Casks Jamaican Rum Read More »

Wilderness Trail 6 Year Kentucky Straight Wheated Bourbon

Wilderness Trail 6 Year Single Barrel Wheated
Family Reserve Cask Strength Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Barrel # 765288; ISC Classic #4
Rickhouse: E-N12-9-15; Yeast Strain: 927

55.2% ABV
$70
Website
Wilderness Trail 6-Year Kentucky Straight Wheated Bourbon
We would like to thank Wilderness Trail Distillery and Allison Worldwide for sending us a sample to review.

What the Distillery Says

Wilderness Trail, the award-winning Kentucky Distillery known for using modern science to optimize old-world distilling traditions, is proud to announce the launch of 6-Year-Old Private Barrel offerings in their single barrel lineup. This marks a notable milestone for the young craft distillery, which was founded only 13 years ago.

The collection features three distinct 6-year-old, single-barrel, cask-strength, non-chill filtered expressions including a Wheated Bourbon, a High-Rye Bourbon, and a Rye Whiskey. Each is meticulously crafted using Wilderness Trail’s Sweet Mash process, proprietary yeast strains, and a Level 4 Alligator Char barrel profile to deliver elevated flavor definition and barrel complexity.

Hand-selected for its distinct character and complexity, each single barrel is a testament to the combination of employing modern fermentation science with traditional Kentucky maturation techniques. Wilderness Trail’s unconventional approach to traditional bourbon-making is crafted for the true whiskey enthusiast looking to explore alternative styles and is best enjoyed neat or on the rocks.

“At six years, our single barrels hit the sweet spot where our sweet mash fermentation and proprietary yeast strains deliver layered complexity without sacrificing balance,” said Dr. Pat Heist, Co-Owner and Chief Scientific Officer of Wilderness Trail Distillery. “The Wheated, High-Rye bourbon, and Rye Whiskey selections let enthusiasts choose between softer high-wheat elegance and the vibrant spice and herbal nuance of rye, each barrel a distinct expression of science meeting tradition.”

Crafted for true whiskey enthusiasts. Each single barrel is hand-selected, bottled at cask strength, and features a high-wheat mashbill for a uniquely soft, rich flavor.

Aged for 6 years, it features a mashbill of 64% corn, 24% wheat, and 12% malted barley using proprietary yeast strains. Aged in a #4 char barrel and entered at 110 proof.

FLAVOR PROFILE
Color: Rich, unfiltered deep amber
Nose: Sweet and nutty.
Taste: Notes of vanilla, caramel, butterscotch, and stone fruit.
Finish: Hints of baking spice, oak, and barrel char.
HOW TO SIP IT
All our whiskeys are best enjoyed neat or on the rocks in a classic sipping glass.
If you’re inclined, you can add a few water droplets to open up their rich aromas. We’ll leave that up to you.

What Gary Says

Nose: Coffee cake with vanilla icing, caramel, cinnamon, oak and a hint of cloves.
Palate: Creamy mouthfeel, caramel, butterscotch, cinnamon, vanilla, nutmeg, pepper spice approaching chili oil.
Finish: Short to moderate in length with oak and pepper spice.
Comments: For the ABV this one drinks a tad hot to me (if I had to guess, I would have put it north of 60%) but a bit of water doesn’t hurt it. In fact a few drops brings out fruit notes on the nose (apples and pears) and tamps down the pepper on the palate, taking the butterscotch over to more of a toffee note. Tried this in an Old Fashioned and it did really well (where I tend to prefer rye-bourbons).

Rating: Stands Out

Wilderness Trail 6 Year Kentucky Straight Wheated Bourbon Read More »