Gary’s Blog

Blind Barrels – Sample Kit Review

Blind Barrels

Price:  See Website for current
As of 10/20/2024
Single box (4 samples): $85 including shipping
Quarterly Subscription (1 box, 4 samples): $59.99 each quarter
Annual Subscription (4 quarterly boxes, 16 samples total): $199.99
Promotions and specials may affect pricing

Blind Barrels
We would like to thank Blind Barrels for sending us a sample kit to review.

What Blind Barrels Says*

* as of 10/20/2024

American Craft Whiskey Club
If you enjoy trying new kinds of whiskey, consider a craft whiskey club subscription from Blind Barrels. We pick top-shelf whiskeys for our members at a discounted price. Our full bottles are a great addition to your whiskey cabinet that you can enjoy yourself or share with a friend. Our American craft whiskey club subscription is also a great gift to give to a friend who loves whiskey. Read on to learn more about our whiskey club.

Our Subscription Process

With each shipment from Blind Barrels, you will get four samples of whiskey bottles. Your first box will ship immediately after you place the order; then, you will get one delivery every quarter (every three months). We look forward to helping you find new whiskey to try.

Other Blind Barrels Products and Services

If you are interested in Blind Barrels merch like hats, drinking glasses, or t-shirts, visit our merch page to purchase these items and wear them with pride. We also offer masterclasses for you to learn more about tasting whiskey, whiskey history, and whiskey recipes.

For more information on joining the craft whiskey club from Blind Barrels, visit our FAQ page. We look forward to helping you discover new whiskey.

How It Works
PICK A SUBSCRIPTION: Sign up yourself or a fellow whiskey lover to the most exclusive top-shelf whiskey club.
SET DELIVERY LOCATION: Curated samples are shipped right to your door every quarter.
ENJOY YOUR NEW DISCOVERIES: Fall in love with a new brand and order member-discounted full bottles to add to your whiskey cabinet.

What Gary Says

Full disclosure – folks who have read our blog are probably aware that I’m not a big fan of most ‘craft whiskey’. While there have been some exceptions, I often find the product just doesn’t compare favorably with similar products from the major distilleries (and is priced super premium). I get the cost advantages that the big companies have, but as a consumer – don’t feel responsible for having to pay the difference. The exception to this is if you can offer me something unique, different, or innovative. So the notion of a tasting kit that focuses on craft whiskey – let’s say I went in with fairly low expectations. Note that

Let’s start with the kit itself. The packaging is solid and well done. Opening the box you’re greeted with a card that details the particular release. The sample I was sent was the June 2024 release, noting to celebrate Father’s day they featured whiskey made by both father-son and father-daughter teams (nice touch). Also noted that a portion of the proceeds from each June box is being donated to Forgotten Not Gone, which I appreciate it.

Blind Barrels Tasting Kit

Removing the card you find the four samples, packed securely in foam and labeled A, B, C and D. Really nice presentation. The back of the card also includes ‘The Tasting Table’ which is a list of notes that one might get with whiskey, starting at a high level and gradually refining. The card also includes instructions to go through the samples once before revealing what they are using the QR code. Appreciate the table, as I’m not ashamed to admit that I have similar tools I like to use when tasting a spirit to try to job the brain as to what aroma or flavor I’m detecting.

Blind Barrels Tasting Kit

The samples themselves are 50 ml, and to follow the required regulations they include a government warning and state in fine print on the back where they were distilled (just the state, not the distillery) as well as the ABV. Appreciate that they keep this small and not draw attention to it; I note it here only so that if you’re wanting to know the least amount of information – you know NOT to look at the back until you’re ready to reveal more details.

Blind Barrels Sample Bottle Back

A 50 mL sample is plenty for someone to do several passes by for nosing tasting. If you’re buying the kit to share, you probably are looking at either only sharing with one other person (if you want to do two small passes), or maybe 3-4 if you only do one pass. Appreciate that the samples were organized from the lowest proof to the highest proof. Any experienced whiskey taster would set it up this way to avoid palate fatigue or burnout from the high proof drams.

I poured maybe 10-12 mL of each into a Glencairn and let them sit for just a few minutes before making my first pass. Just on the nose the four samples were all very different, which is good. While some may enjoy a really narrow tasting (like four bourbons all from the same distillery and mashbill, but at different ages/proofs/rick house aging locations), it can be challenging for those who don’t really geek out on those details. These were all quite different.

I didn’t do very well at guessing what they were. Below is a brief description of my impressions of each, followed by what they are. If you want to read all of the details (or watch the video they share for the tasting), the URL from the QR code is https://blindbarrels.com/pages/0624.

Sample A
Nose was very rye-like, herbal with mint, bit of citrus, cedar – but a little funky; intriguing! The palate had a creamy mouthfeel, with mint, lemon, caramel and a hint of cinnamon.
I guessed this was a rye whiskey with a lot of barley in the mashbill (like 70% rye, 10% corn and 20% barley). Of the four samples, this is the one I enjoyed the most, as it was very intriguing but also quite enjoyable to sip.
[Sample A: Axe Hole Single Malt Whiskey]

Sample B
Nose was very unique, funky with oak and carpet. On the palate, I got herbal notes of cloves and anise, and thought as strange as this was it must be a craft single malt. This was my least favorite of the samples as it was just odd and not in my wheelhouse.
[Sample B: UNBendt Straight Rye Whiskey Bottled-in-Bond]

Sample C
Nose definitely was telegraphing a wine influence, between sherry or marsala, with notes of maple syrup behind the fruit. ON the palate it was malty, with maple, chocolate and a bit of pepper and tarragon. I was at a loss for the type of spirit, as it made me think more of a scotch with different wood management than anything else.
[Sample C: Old Monongahela Full Proof Rye Whiskey]

Sample D
Nose was richer than the others, with caramel and some chocolate, as well as a grassy note. On the palate it was thick and rich with vanilla, caramel, chocolate and nutty notes. This was the highest proof dram and it stood out (61% ABV), with a bit of a burn. I did peg this as a bourbon, and thought maybe a wheater. This was a close 2nd to Sample A as my favorite, although if I was just looking for one to kick back and enjoy I’d go for this.
[Sample D: Doc Holliday 10 Year Straight Bourbon Whiskey]

While not especially a fan of most craft whiskey, and wasn’t particularly fond of a couple of these samples – I absolutely enjoyed the tasting experience! It was fun to try to guess what they were without having any details (while the proof was listed, after I noticed it on the first I didn’t look at the backs of the others until I was done). If you are a fan of craft whiskey, or are starting out on your whiskey journey and trying to figure out what you like and what you don’t – this is a fun way to learn about some different whiskies. This would make a fun whiskey experience gift for someone as well – or for a couple (or couple of friends). This is definitely geared more for the younger (legal drinking age or higher) generation. My dad would enjoy the blind tasting, but lacking a smartphone and having no idea what a QR code is – would have been left out. I like how the site has the samples in envelopes. One recommendation I’d offer is to include the ‘reveal’ in the kit itself but in an envelope with a warning to NOT open; for those few consumers who may not be technologically savvy (although this very likely isn’t in their target demographic).

Cheers!

Gary

Blind Barrels – Sample Kit Review Read More »

Yellowstone Bourbon Launches Once-in-a-Lifetime Getaway Contest

Yellowstone Bourbon Launches Once-in-a-Lifetime Getaway Contest

Iconic bourbon brand shares its connection to America’s first national park with consumers through new adventure experience opportunity

Yellowstone Bourbon Launches Once-in-a-Lifetime Getaway Contest
ST. LOUIS (April 8, 2024) – Yellowstone Bourbon announced a contest for consumers to win an all-inclusive trip to Yellowstone National Park in 2024. Consumers can enter the Yellowstone National Park Getaway Contest now through July 15 by submitting a photo and a writeup about their love for the great outdoors – a hiking story, poem or another kind of written expression.

The three lucky winners and their plus-one will experience the ultimate national park adventure September 5-8, 2024, including hiking, horseback riding, sightseeing, curated meals, private accommodations and round-trip airfare. In addition, four social media influencers will join the winners for this trip of a lifetime:
• Dean Unglert, reality TV star and outdoor explorer
• Adam Glick, celebrity chef and adventurer
• Holly Johnson, travel and outdoor content creator
• Patrick Duke, adventure photographer and filmmaker

“For more than 150 years, Yellowstone Bourbon has shared a bond with the majestic Yellowstone National Park,” said Kelly Panzitta, Yellowstone Bourbon brand manager. “This contest gives people the opportunity to experience that connection firsthand and win a one-of-a-kind adventure. It’s part of our commitment to always keep the park within reach.”

Since 2018, Yellowstone Bourbon has donated nearly $500,000 to National Parks Conservation Association to preserve national parks. In 2023, Yellowstone became one of NPCA’s largest annual corporate donors at the $250,000 level.

Yellowstone Bourbon partnered with World Playground to plan the contest itinerary and Under Canvas for the winners’ and influencers’ private accommodations in West Yellowstone. For more information about the contest including official rules, please visit Yellowstone National Park Getaway Contest or YellowstoneBourbon.com. For updates about the contest, follow Yellowstone Bourbon on Facebook and Instagram.

Yellowstone Bourbon Launches Once-in-a-Lifetime Getaway Contest Read More »

About that 700 mL Bottle . . .

We’re all adults here (or should be if you’re reading a whiskey/whisky blog).

Should anyone be surprised to start seeing domestic offerings at 700 mL versus 750 mL? No, although I’m sure some will feign shock and awe at the prospect.

Am I crazy about it? No, but I’m not backing down from my elation over the change in the Standards of Fill.

Have the floodgates opened with more independent bottlings here in the United States? Maybe not as much as I’d hoped – although supply chain, tariffs, inflation and other factors are likely contributing to that.

Will we see a price break when folks convert bottles from 750 to 700? I’d bet not. But I still think it is the right move as it makes production more efficient and opens up more markets to producers. A smaller producer who can’t afford to buy inventory of two different sized bottles just to be able to sell in other markets now won’t have to worry about that.

In the case of my recent review, one of the first domestic offerings I’ve seen in 700 mL – I’d note that this is a new offering; not a migration of an existing brand that was sold at 750 mL previously. A 6 year, bottled-in-bond rye, at $50. If they kept the ‘price per ounce’ the same and offered it in a 750 mL, it’d be $53.57. Does that difference impact my desire to buy it? Not a chance. I get that as the prices go up – the difference does as well, that’s just math. Essentially for a brand migrating, the customer is losing 1.7 oz in the bargain (and if you’re talking about a $150 bottle, now that gaps is just over $10).

My guess is that given the current inflationary environment, the big brands will start to make that move and keep prices level (which I get is ‘shrinkflation’). It isn’t that I think the big brands are altruistic or any shit like that, but rather that it’s a convenient excuse to make the cut and explain why they aren’t dropping prices when they do (although if you’re the last one to make that move, it might be shrewd to discount and call out the other greedy bastards).

At the end of the day, your daily drinker of $20-$30, you’re talking about a difference of $1.50-$2. Let’s be honest – if (let’s say Jack Daniels, or Jim Beam, or Evan Williams) is your drink of choice, you’re not switching to one of those others over $1.50 difference. That’s not why you’re with that brand.

I do hope that we will start to see more and more offerings here in the States in the not too distant future. Offerings which we could only have dreamt of before (or paid exorbitant amounts to have shipped from the far side of the pond). Again, not because I think the industry is altruistic – but because there’s a lot of money to be made in doing so. Just wasn’t enough to support bottling at 750 mL just for one goofy market.

About that 700 mL Bottle . . . Read More »

Barrell Craft Spirits® Launches Sample Gift Box

Barrell Craft Spirits® Launches Sample Gift Box

Just in Time for the Holidays, the Original Independent Blender Offers
100ml samples of its Core Whiskey Expressions and Newest Batched Bourbon

Barrell Craft Spirits Sample Gift Box

Louisville, KY (September 5, 2023) – Barrell Craft Spirits® (BCS), the original independent blender of unique aged, cask strength whiskey since 2013, today launched a gift box containing 100ml samples of its core Barrell products – Dovetail, Seagrass, Vantage – and its newest batch release, Barrell Bourbon Batch 035.

  • Barrell Dovetail
    • A blend of whiskeys finished in blackstrap rum, Port, and Dunn Vineyards Cabernet barrels. A uniquely delicious whiskey with a buttery texture and rich, spicy depth.
  • Barrell Seagrass
    • A blend of Canadian and American rye whiskeys finished in Martinique rum, Madeira, and apricot brandy barrels. Ripe, juicy fruit sits at the core of this whiskey, wrapped by layers of leather, grassy herbs, and rye spice.
  • Barrell Vantage
    • A blend of straight bourbons finished in three distinct expressions of virgin oak: Mizunara, French, and toasted American oak casks. The result is a warm, elegant bourbon that highlights the many dimensions of oak.
  • Barrell Bourbon Batch 035
    • A blend of 6, 7, 8, and 13-year-old bourbons. The resulting bourbon is peppery and intriguing on the nose, and sweet and long on the finish.

“Many consumers appreciate the opportunity to sample an ultra-premium whiskey before purchasing a 750ml bottle,” said BCS Founder Joe Beatrice. “Our sample gift box is the perfect way to try before you buy. It also makes an ideal holiday stocking stuffer for adult whiskey enthusiasts.”

Founded in 2013 in Louisville, Kentucky, BCS selects and blends products that explore different distillation methods, barrels, and aging environments, and bottles them at cask strength. BCS’s extensive stocks of high-quality casks mean it can craft extraordinary blends that maximize the nuances of each ingredient. Creative finishes, a liberated approach to blending, and a deep-seated commitment to releasing each whiskey at cask strength guides every product release.

Beginning October 1, the sample gift box is available for purchase online via the BCS website at barrellbourbon.com and in select retail locations across the U.S. for the suggested retail price of $69.99.

The award-winning line of Barrell Craft Spirits releases are currently sold in 49 US states. For more information, follow Barrell Craft Spirits® on FacebookLinkedIn, and Instagram or visit barrellbourbon.com.

 Barrell Craft Spirits®

Louisville-based Barrell Craft Spirits® is the original, pre-eminent independent blender of unique, aged, cask strength whiskey and rum. Recognized for our blending expertise since 2013, we skillfully design, produce, and launch leading, unique products that surprise and delight whiskey aficionados and novices alike.

Barrell Craft Spirits®, Barrell®, Barrell Bourbon® and Barrell Rye® are registered trademarks owned by Barrell Craft Spirits LLC.

Barrell Craft Spirits® Launches Sample Gift Box Read More »

What bourbon is worth secondary market pricing?

I get asked this question by folks who haven’t had the opportunity to experience some of these gems.  I also get asked this question by folks who “know a guy” who can get them something but they’re not sure if the price is worth while (and who don’t really care what it tastes like).

Let me start with clarifying that this is NOT an investment post.  I’m going to tackle this from the perspective of someone considering buying a bottle to open up and drink. Might you be able to buy a bottle today at secondary market pricing and sell it in the future for more?  Who knows.  Every time I think the pricing has gotten “too crazy”, I hear some outrageous example that proves me wrong. Price/value is highly subjective – what I may feel is “too much” may be an amount that is chump change to someone else, so leaving that up to you.

And while I would like to say the answer to the question is “None are worth it” – that would be a bit disingenuous since I’ve had the privilege of experiencing first hand what some of these highly sought after pours are – without paying secondary market pricing.  As Garth Brooks says, I’ve got friends in low places 🙂  I consider myself unbelievably lucky to have gotten into bourbon in 2010, finding my way to other enthusiasts who had been in the hobby for many years – some a decade or more.  They had accumulated some amazing collections, including glut-era dusties from all of the major distilleries.  They educated me on how to spot a dusty (what UPC codes were associated with older distilleries, when tax stamps were “a thing”, etc) and were generous enough to share some truly amazing bottles (like single barrel, non-chill filtered Stitzel Weller distilled Pappy Van Winkle; or Willett 22 yr Rye barrel 618 aka ‘Doug’s Green Ink’).

Were many of those better than what I could walk into a store and pick off a shelf today in 2022?  Feel pretty confident answering in the affirmative.  In fact the Willett 22 yr remains to this day the best rye whiskey I’ve ever tasted.  If I could buy a bottle – knowing what it tastes like – I would absolutely pay multiples of what it was purchased for originally (which I believe Smokin’ Joe recalled to be under $100 a bottle). Last I heard, it is going for several thousand a bottle.  Would I pay that?  No chance in hell.

But there are a lot of bottles that having tried them, in my opinion, aren’t that special and are over-hyped. I wouldn’t pay over retail for Blanton’s, Henry McKenna 10 Yr, any Weller or Pappy. That isn’t to say they’re not good whiskey – they are. But in my experience, there are some single barrel private picks from different distilleries that I’d take over those every time. Some Buffalo Trace Antique Collection bottles I’ve had were really spectacular – and I honestly would probably pay double retail for some (although again, this isn’t where the market is at). But at $500+ a bottle – I’m passing every single time.

The way I think about it is this: What would I be willing to pay for the experience itself – knowing that it might not live up to the hype?

Let’s say that you’ve never had a George T Stagg, and you have a chance to buy one for $1,200 a bottle.  Let’s also assume this is through a reputable retailer, where the provenance isn’t in question (although may not be that reputable if they’re selling at that price).  The way I would think about it is this:

  1. What is it worth to me have a 2 oz pour, in the setting (and using the glassware) of my choosing? Because to get a 1 oz pour, I’ll likely be paying $75-$100 in a restaurant that may have a ton of aromas going on, noise, etc (and who knows about the glassware)  Am I willing to pay less than that rate and have the chance to pick my setting/glassware?
  2. How many friends or acquaintances might be interested in the same experience?  Considering a 750 mL bottle is 25.36 ounces (call it 25), that’s 12 solid 2 oz pours with a bit extra.  If I can get 11 friends willing to chip in $100 a piece for 2 oz of Stagg, I’m paying the same thing (but getting a tad over 3 oz). Hell, a friend who has had it might be game since it is below on premise pricing.   Even if I can only get 5 others – I’ve cut back my risk almost in half (and if I like it, will have half a bottle left!)

This was a long post to get to this point:  Think of it as an experience.  People pay over $200 to jump out of a perfectly good airplane – and from when you jump you’re back on the ground in about 10 minutes.  I could savor a 2 oz pour of a delicious whiskey for a helluva lot longer than 10 minutes.  And doing so with friends makes it all the more enjoyable.

What bourbon is worth secondary market pricing? Read More »